Oregon's catastrophic 2026 wildfire season is reigniting a contentious legal and policy debate: when utilities and landowners face massive lawsuit exposure for wildfires, does the threat of litigation actually make forests more dangerous by discouraging the prescribed burns needed to reduce fuel loads?
The PacifiCorp Case
The question gained fresh relevance in April 2026 when an Oregon appeals court reversed a landmark jury verdict against PacifiCorp, the large utility that provides electricity to approximately 2.1 million customers across six Western states. A 2023 jury had awarded 17 plaintiffs $67.5 million in pain and suffering damages related to the catastrophic 2020 Labor Day fires in Oregon โ fires that killed 11 people and displaced tens of thousands of residents. The appellate reversal, based on improper jury instructions, did not resolve the underlying liability questions, and the case remains in litigation.
Prescribed Burn Liability Chilling Effects
A separate but related concern involves the chilling effect of wildfire litigation on prescribed burning programs. Fire managers and land management agencies have expressed concern that the threat of liability suits โ particularly in a legal environment where multibillion-dollar verdicts are possible โ is making prescribed burn programs more difficult to execute.
Some states have moved to create liability shields for prescribed burn practitioners. Oregon has established such a fund, though as of November 2026, no claims have yet been filed under it โ nor has California's similar fund seen any activity. The effectiveness of these protections in truly enabling an expansion of prescribed burning at the scale needed remains an open question.
The Policy Tension
At the heart of the debate is a fundamental tension: the same legal system designed to hold utilities and landowners accountable for fire starts may be inadvertently making it harder to prevent the next catastrophic fire by discouraging the controlled burns that most fire scientists agree are essential to restoring forest resilience.
- Prescribed burns reduce dangerous fuel loads but carry a small risk of escape
- Litigation risk makes agencies and landowners more hesitant to burn
- Reduced burning leads to increased fuel accumulation
- Higher fuel loads contribute to more catastrophic wildfires
What Needs to Happen
Fire scientists, policymakers, and legal scholars broadly agree that addressing this tension requires a combination of stronger liability protections for prescribed burn practitioners, clearer regulatory frameworks governing when and how burns can occur, and increased public investment in professional burn crews who can conduct treatments safely and effectively.
The Fix Our Forests Act, currently advancing in Congress, includes provisions related to liability and administrative reform that supporters say could help remove barriers to prescribed burning on federal lands. Similar reforms at the state level are expected to be a focus of Oregon's 2027 legislative session, as lawmakers grapple with the aftermath of the most destructive fire year in state history.